Obsidian vs Logseq conundrum

Posted by Daly de Gagne
Apr 12, 2024 at 05:49 PM

Dormouse, you make an interesting point about a traditional outline or mindmap program being better.

Would you agree that a traditional analogue approach - using a pen and index card in the spirit of Luhmann migh also be better than the digital approach?

Thanks.

Daly

Dormouse wrote:

>
>Tumbleweed wrote:
>It can be made into a Zettlekasten
>>with links, which should be more deliberate.
>>
> >I was never happy with zettelkasten in Obsidian etc.
>Partly notes inclined towards long. The links carry no indication of a
>train of thought and, in practice, links on a note can reflect very
>distant trains of thought. And convenient workflows are rarely
>zettelkasten related.
> >And when it comes to it I came down on the folgezettel being important
>side of the debate.
>And a traditional outline/mindmap automatically has a folgezettel
>structure. So long as the placement of a note is done with zettelkasten
>deliberation it’s all good, and there’s an inclination to short notes
>rather than long. And links and backlinks can still be done.